Buy or Sell

Ordering cards

Need cards?  You can submit a card list to us via email.  We will pull your order and have it ready for you when you come in!  We ask that you submit your list at least 24 hours in advance.  Please paste the following information into the email:

Your name:
Preferred contact method and phone # (email, phone, text message):
I will pick up my order by:

What is the minimum acceptable card condition?  Mint/NearMint (M/NM) cards, LightPlay/ModeratelyPlay/HeavyPlay (LP/MP/HP) cards at a discount if available? (all cards will be sleeve playable):

Are you okay with variants like full art, promos, or foils based on availability? :
If so, how much of a price difference are you willing to accept?

cardlist@gametimeindy.com

A few notes about this service…

  1. Your list must be in a printable text format.  We cannot use any sort of attachments, links, screenshots or photos.  It’s also extremely helpful if its sorted alphabetically.
  2. Please be aware of the cost of the cards you are ordering.  We generally reference TCGplayer.com for card pricing.  We also use a floor pricing model, where commons and uncommons are a minimum of .25, and rares and mythic rares are a minimum of .50.
  3. There may be cards that we don’t have in stock.  See above regarding variant substitutions.
  4. We will contact you when your order is ready.
  5. Orders are usually processed in the order in which they are received.  It is best to submit your order at least one day in advance, especially if it is a large list.
  6. Please have your order finalized before you submit it.
  7. We reserve the right to decline an order.  This is generally only done with customers who have submitted and then cancelled or failed to pick up lists in the past.

Questions?  Give us a call! 
317-577-0900

Looking to sell?

It is our mission to be the best buyers around.  We do our best to pay more than our competitors,  in CASH or store credit.  Game Time buys collections of any size, no collection too big or too small.

Magic the Gathering
Pokemon
YuGiOh (bulk only)
RPG books
Miniatures (Star Wars, Pathfinder, D&D and others)

So much more!  If you have something you would like to sell, give us a call or drop in.
You must be at least 18 or have your parent with you to sell or trade items to us.
A valid US Drivers License/ID is required to sell to us.

Questions?  Give us a call!
317-577-0900